In recent years, foreign films have taken the horror genre by storm with such titles as Parasite (2019), Raw (2016), and Veronica (2017). The Argentinian director Demián Rugna‘s 2023 film, When Evil Lurks aims to join the ranks of such foreign films with a new take on possession and a mix of supernatural horror and psychological horror. Where it falls short, though, is the implementation of stale horror tropes (possessed children anyone?) and its reliance on shock and gore to cover for its less-than-stellar plot.
When Evil Lurks starts with a bang, sucking the audience into its somewhat dystopian landscape immediately. Two brothers stumble across a mutilated corpse in the woods near their house and discover a briefcase of bizarre tools alongside the body. Before they can make heads or tails of this, they find themselves at a ramshackle house containing a family: a mother, a son, and a second son who is a rotten pile of pustules and ooze. The brothers immediately panic and begin searching for help to call in an expert who specializes in dealing with “the Rotten”, but to no avail. What ensues is an almost comedic trip to dealing with him themselves.
It is after this that the movie starts to drag. The plot gets a bit convoluted with needless tension between one of the main characters and his ex-wife, a few irritating kids, and a needless side story about one of the brothers’ past lovers. Furthermore, what could be an interesting genre mash-up of demon possession and blood-and-pus zombie types is, instead, just a confusing mess.
One of the major letdowns of When Evil Lurks is its reliance on tired horror tropes. The small-town setting with a dark secret, the ominous background music, possessed kids, and the predictable jump scares all contribute to a sense of déjà vu, delivering a recycled compilation of horror elements we’ve seen countless times before. The film lacks the innovation needed to stand out in an oversaturated genre.
While When Evil Lurks does have its moments of suspense and several truly remarkable moments of gross-out horror, these are overshadowed by a lack of originality and a failure to bring anything fresh to the horror genre. The film’s potential to explore deeper themes is squandered in favor of recycled scares and a by-the-numbers plot.
In the end, When Evil Lurks fails to live up to the expectations set by its intriguing premise, leaving horror enthusiasts longing for a more inventive and engaging cinematic experience.
More Film Reviews
Detention (2011) Film Review – Never Going Back to My Old School
Imagine if, in the early 1980s, nascent film directors John Hughes and Wes Craven met up with venerable science fiction author Ray Bradbury at a Northern California artist’s retreat. There,…
Sweetie, You Won’t Believe It Movie Review – Fantasia Festival 2021
Fishing doesn’t have the best reputation in fiction. Going off literature and film and Dick Cheney, one gets the impression it’s boring, it’s vaguely cruel, and it mostly serves as…
Eri’s Murder Diary Film Review – The Broken Mind Of A Killer
Proposing itself as an intimate look at a killer, Eri’s Murder Diary (2021) caught my attention among the many titles at Japan Film Fest Hamburg. Directed by newcomer Koji Degura,…
Dark Windows (2023) Film Review – Through Rose-Tinted Glasses
Dark Windows is a 2023 American horror written by Ulrvik Kraft and directed by Alex Herron in his first feature-length film. Three teenagers, who were all involved in the fatal car…
V/H/S/94 (2021) Film Review – Found Footage Series Back With Vengeance
When the first V/H/S film was initially released in 2012, its impact on the horror community was immediately felt, creating shocking scenarios presented in intimate detail through the found footage…
M3GAN (2022) Film Review – The Creepy, Dancing Doll that Captured our Hearts
In the Fall of 2022, the horror movie community got a jolt when the trailer for director Gerard Johnstone’s and screenwriter Akela Cooper’s sci-fi/horror film, M3GAN, dropped. The trailer’s…
As lover of cryptids, literature, and all things horror, I am so excited to be bringing my talents to the Grimoire of Horror. I am a librarian, avid gamer, TTRPG nerd, and a Mothman fangirl. I spent several years screening films for PRIMAA’s Canadian film festival Reel Shorts, and spent some time as an amateur horror filmmaker, competing in the Frantic 48 filmmaking challenge several years in a row. I love anything horror, from true crime to grindhouse to found footage and am especially interested in horror books and movies created by LGBTQIA2S+ and BIPOC as I think we have a fresh take on the genre and a fascinating perspective on what horror can be.