Anyone who’s been in a car accident understands disorientation; the lack of clarity of what just happened, the realization that time does indeed slow down, it’s not some old wife’s tale and the difficulty one has in collecting themselves after the chaos.

That appears to be Cecilia’s (Moro Anghileri) problem. She’s lost, at first in the literal sense, her son in a car wreck with a truck carrying a mysterious crate. When she wakes up in the hospital, her son and the other driver are missing, as is a witness. And that mysterious crate has opened up. That’s the setup for Daniel De La Vega’s On The Third Day, an Argentinian horror film that’s more alive when you’re in the same kind of daze as its lead.

There’s a lot to unpack in a film whose runtime is less than 90 minutes, though much of it would involve spoilers. One might think the film title is a dead giveaway, but they’d only be half-right. Since part of the joy of films like Day is the mystery, it’s best to speak vaguely.

On The Third Day review

After waking up in the hospital, suspicions fall on the only one found, and Cecilia has no memory of the events after the accident. Only a doctor seems willing to help, the police and her abusive ex-husband are instantly accusatory. It’s very clear Cecilia has been controlled by the men in her life, she can’t even get her ex to leave at an agreed-upon time.

Anghileri has to walk a pretty fine line, and she’s certainly up to it. We’re never meant to entirely trust her, even though we have little reason not to. Her cipher-like performance only further contributes to the intentionally overwhelming bewilderment of the first half.

But, Day isn’t interested in dwelling on the causes and reasons of what’s happening, and it’s a better film for it. It’s that mystifying disorientation that keeps it working, the mystery is engaging even for those who called it early. For the first half, audiences could be easily torn between what the ultimate reveal is. It’s not that the twist is difficult to see coming, only that De La Vega conceals it amid religious jargon and imagery. It also helps that Day exists in a contained setting, not having much interest in a Catholic Church conspiracy that’s only paid brief attention.

On The Third Day review

It’s one thing for a film to establish its creeping sense of dread, it’s another entirely to maintain the length of the runtime. De La Vega accomplishes this in part through subterfuge, but also by employing some of the oldest tricks in the book. It’s nice to know things like hypnotism scenes with metronomes and Vertigo shots can still pack some punch. 

Ultimately, however, the reveal is still a reveal. Positively, it’s well-handled with a great ghoulish creature. It’s not the most original monster in cinema, but it’s certainly haunting. Still, concealing a surprise that is not much of one, or any depending on the viewer, is always going to be a bit of a letdown. If, of course, it’s looked at as a twist, as I imagine many will. In reality, it’s a logical progression. 

It’s an ending that gets thematically richer upon reflection, and a refreshing road toward one of the oldest monsters in the genre. And it’s a fun ride getting there.

This article was originally written by Kenny Hedges for Grimoire of Horror.

More from Fantasia Film Festival:

H.P. Lovecraft’s The Old Ones is a 2023 splatter/cosmic horror film, written and directed by Chad Ferrin. Known for his over-the-top special effects, Ferrin is the creative mind behind Pig…

As an Emmy Award winner, Richard T. Wilson serves as the President/Writer-Filmmaker of RTW Productions, Inc., home to the nationally recognized educational film company, Outreach Arts, Inc., and its award-winning,…

The Illustrated Guide to Monster Girls is a 4-volume, light-hearted horror/slice-of-life manga, written and illustrated by Suzu Akeko. A prolific manga creator, she has previously written and illustrated Nightmare Eater,…

Here at the Grimoire of Horror, we were excited to take a look at the second volume of Halloween Girl, entitled Dead Reckoning. You can see our thoughts on the…

Every year horror fans are inundated with a slew of holiday-themed horror, with a select few becoming instant classics. Even at Fantastic Fest, where we caught There’s Something in The…

Mushrooms, originally known as Grzyby, is a Polish 2023 mystery thriller, written and directed by Paweł Borowski. Beginning his directorial career with the short animated comedy Love Gamestation (2001), Paweł…

Tammy lives a regular teenage life, with an overbearing bible-thumping mother-in-law who hates filth and a father who would do anything for her daughter, whether it be beheading a donkey…

Door is a 1988 Japanese psychological horror thriller written and directed by Banmei Takahashi with additional writing from Ataru Oikawa. Beginning his career in Pinku Eiga in the 70s, Takahashi…

  Visitors (Complete Edition) is a Japanese 2023 Splatter horror comedy, written and directed by Kenichi Ugana. Beginning his theatrical debut in 2016 with the “Gal film” Ganguro Gals Riot…

Fishmonger is a 2023 Irish supernatural horror comedy, written and directed by Neil Ferron with additional writing from Alexandra Dennis-Renner. Not his first time behind the camera, Neil is known…